Up to 38.6% of people with colon cancer who have a hereditary cancer syndrome — including 6.3% of those with Lynch syndrome — could have their conditions remain undetected with current universal tumor-screening methods, and at least 7.1% of people with colorectal cancer have an identifiable inherited genetic mutation, according to new data published by scientists at The Ohio State University Comprehensive Cancer Center – Arthur G. James Cancer Hospital and Richard J. Solove Research Institute (OSUCCC – James).
Experts say their data, which was gathered from a cohort of more than 3,300 colorectal cancer patients treated at 51 hospitals across Ohio, makes a strong scientific argument for implementing multi-gene panel testing as part of the standard of care for all colorectal cancer patients.
“Finding ways to identify high-risk individuals among colorectal cancer patients is critically needed to better manage this disease and proactively identify family members who may also be impacted,” says Rachel Pearlman, MS, LGC, first author of the study and a genetic counselor/researcher at the OSUCCC – James. “Genetic screening has changed dramatically in the past 10 years, allowing us to screen individuals for numerous known genetic mutations for much lower costs. This is a powerful tool that we need to embrace more broadly for cancer prevention and surveillance.”
Study Methods and Results
For this study, OSUCCC – James researchers wanted to know if using a multi-level genetic testing approach could better identify hereditary genetic risk factors (passed down through families) that dramatically increase a person’s lifetime risk of cancer but often go undetected until cancer occurs.
Researchers identified 3,310 adults who had undergone surgery for invasive colorectal cancer from January 2013 to December 2016. Individuals were recruited as part of the Pelotonia-funded Ohio Colorectal Cancer Prevention Initiative (OCCPI), a statewide research initiative led by Heather Hampel, MS, LGC. Hampel is a member of the OSUCCC – James Molecular Carcinogenesis and Chemoprevention Program, as well as a professor and associate director of the Division of Human Genetics at the Ohio State College of Medicine.
The study was launched to screen newly diagnosed colorectal cancer patients and their biological relatives for Lynch syndrome, a cancer-causing condition that occurs if a person inherits a mutation in one of four genes. People with Lynch syndrome are at higher risk to develop colorectal, endometrial (uterine), ovarian and stomach cancer than average-risk individuals.
All study participants received universal tumor screening for mismatch repair (MMR) deficiency. This characteristic is common in tumors from patients with Lynch syndrome and suggests that the tumor would respond well to immunotherapy, which is a novel cancer treatment using your body’s own immune system to fight the tumor, if necessary.
Individuals who met at least one of the trial-inclusion criteria also received multi-gene panel testing to identify harmful mutations. Genetic testing criteria included: MMR deficiency; colorectal cancer diagnosis before age 50; multiple primary tumors (colorectal cancer/endometrial cancer); or a first-degree relative with colorectal or endometrial cancer.
Researchers report in this new analysis that about 16% (525 patients) of participants had MMR deficiency, and about 7% had an inherited mutation. The scientists note that if universal tumor screening for Lynch syndrome had been the only method used to screen for hereditary cancer syndromes, more than 38% of patients who tested positive would have been missed — including more than 6% of individuals found to have Lynch syndrome through multi-gene testing methods.
“This is a significant and important discovery. By using pan-cancer multi-gene panel testing for all colorectal cancer patients, we could identify many individuals who are at increased risk for future cancer development and identify actionable therapeutic targets for their current cancer,” says Hampel, senior author of the study. “Adopting modern testing methods as part of standard clinical practice for patients with colorectal cancer could literally save thousands of lives through early detection and surveillance of other family members who are at increased risk to develop the cancer based on inherited genetic mutations.”
Co-authors in the study include Wendy Frankel, MD; Benhamin Swanson, MD; Dan Jones, MD, PhD; Weiqiang Zhao, MD, PHD; Rachel Pearlman, MS, CGC; Ahmet Yilmaz, PhD; Kristin Miller, BS; Jason Bacher, BA; Christopher Bigley, MS; Lori Nelsen, BA; Paul J. Goodfellow, PhD; Richard M. Goldberg, MD; Electra Paskett, PhD, MSPH; Peter G. Shields, MD; Jo L. Freudenheim, PhD; Peter P. Stanich, MD; Ilene Lattimer, BSN; Mark Arnold, MD; Thomas W. Prior, PhD; Mitchell Haut, MD; Matthew F. Kalady, MD; Brandie Heald, MS, CGC; Ian Paquette, MD; David J. Draper, MD; Joanna M. Brell, MD; Sameer Mahesh, MD; Kisa Weeman, MD; Shyamal Bastola, MD; Jeffrey Zangmeister, MD; Aruna Gowda, MD; Filix Kencana, MD; Albert Malcolm, MD; Yinong Liu, MD; Sharon Cole, MD; Charles Bane, MD; Chaoyang Li, MD; Esther Rehmus, MD; Colin C. Pritchard, MD, PhD; Brian H. Shirts, MD, PhD; Angela Jacobson, MS, CGC; Shelly A. Cummings, MS, CGC; Albert de la Chapelle, MD, PhD; and Heather Hampel, MS, LGC.
Featured image: Heather Hampel and Rachel Pearlman with Albert de la Chapelle © OSU
Reference: Rachel Pearlman, Wendy L. Frankel, Benjamin J. Swanson, Dan Jones, Weiqiang Zhao, Ahmet Yilmaz, Kristin Miller, Jason Bacher, Christopher Bigley, Lori Nelsen, Paul J. Goodfellow, Richard M. Goldberg, Electra Paskett, Peter G. Shields, Jo L. Freudenheim, Peter P. Stanich, Ilene Lattimer, Mark Arnold, Thomas W. Prior, Mitchell Haut, Matthew F. Kalady, Brandie Heald, Ian Paquette, David J. Draper, Joanna M. Brell, Sameer Mahesh, Kisa Weeman, Shyamal Bastola, Jeffrey Zangmeister, Aruna Gowda, Filix Kencana, Albert Malcolm, Yinong Liu, Sharon Cole, Charles Bane, Chaoyang Li, Esther Rehmus, Colin C. Pritchard, Brian H. Shirts, Angela Jacobson, Shelly A. Cummings, Albert de la Chapelle, and Heather Hampel, “Prospective Statewide Study of Universal Screening for Hereditary Colorectal Cancer: The Ohio Colorectal Cancer Prevention Initiative”, Precision Oncology no. 5 (2021) 779-791. Published online May 5, 2021.
Provided by Ohio State University